Make it Your Own:
We tend to remember things that happen directly to us and have more of a personal meaning behind it. So, make the story your own. Not to mention, by making the story personal or putting your own personal twist on it, the audience will be even more engrossed in what you are saying. Don’t worry about plagiarism. You are telling a story around a camp fire, you are not writing a book.
(For example):
Let’s switch the (Man) to… well (You). Why not? The young boy can still be the young boy or switch it to young girl, depending on your audience. I find if I am telling this story around a group of girls, I will switch it to young girl. Don’t be afraid to make the youth a teenager or any age or culture you want. Again, it’s just a story.